Worth The Money? Eyeko Black Magic Mascara & Skinny Liquid Eyeliner

Since its re-design and re-launch a couple of years ago, Eyeko have positioned themselves as a beauty brand to be reckoned with. Partnering with Alexa Chung was just the tip of the iceberg for this previously cute budget range; they’re now charging a whopping £18.00 for a mascara and £12.00 for an eyeliner – priced to parallel some of the most premium brands out there. Although their mascara has developed a cult-like status amongst its fans, it’s a hit or miss product for many others and has been reformulated numerous times. Having not used an Eyeko product in many years, I was keen to find out what had changed to allow them to double their prices and sign up famous faces to endorse their brand. So, is Eyeko worth the money?

Now available in Midnight Blue (to subtly provide a hint of azur to bring out the whites of your eyes,) Eyeko’s Black Magic mascara combines three key elements to create drama, volume and curl all in one. The curvaceous brush lifts lashes and enables you to cover each individually, for a voluminous and separated result. Unlike a lot of mascaras which focus on either creating volume or lengthening lashes, Black Magic does everything in one swoop and can be built up without unsightly clumping. The iconic squeezy tube isn’t just for fun either, as it allows you to get every last drop of mascara out of the bottle (rather than playing a guessing game as to how much formula is left in your tube.) The dark blue shade is surprisingly wearable, providing an almost undetectable tint to lashes; it helps to make the whites of your eyes pop and make you appear more ‘awake’, which is a bonus if you lead as hectic a life as me.

The Skinny Liquid Eyeliner is easy to apply and contains a long-lasting formula to ensure your look stays jet black all day long. Its precision tip makes it super simple to create feline flicks and definition to accentuate eyes, with no smudging or bleeding around the lash line. I’m useless at applying liquid eyeliner, but this makes it easy for even a novice to create a flawless result. You can build up the line easily thanks to the thin tip, so starting small can end up being big (if you’re so inclined!) I’ve never before been able to master the perfect cat’s eye flick, until this Skinny Liquid Eyeliner graced my hand and changed my makeup repertoire forever; my friends even asked me where I went to have my eyeliner professionally applied when I debuted my new look.

I really do like these two products and would happily part with £12.00 for the Skinny Liquid Eyeliner, but £18.00 for an Eyeko mascara is a little too much for me. Although the result is great and the wand helps to create fanned out lashes, £18.00 takes it into premium territory and near the price of my beloved YSL and Guerlain creations. Eyeko have done a great job at creating some fab products and re-launching themselves as a credible makeup brand, but in my opinion they’d do much better if they reduced their prices a little and let the formulations do the talking.

Are you a fan of Eyeko? Have you tried these new formulas? Would you pay £18.00 for an Eyeko mascara when there are comparable premium alternatives? 

The Black Magic mascara is £18.00, while the Skinny Liquid Eyeliner is £12.00. Both available from Selfridges, Harvey Nichols and online.



  1. Brittany Seel
    March 5, 2014 / 2:50 pm

    I'd love to try the eye liner but never knew where it was available to buy so I'm so pleased you did this post!Bea xBea's Beauty Blog

  2. daisy walters
    March 5, 2014 / 2:51 pm

    Looks really good! xxx | daisydaisyxxo

  3. Charlotte MacDonald-Gaunt
    March 5, 2014 / 3:53 pm

    The skinny liquid eyeliner sounds like something we all need in our lives :o) XxMakeup by Candlelight

  4. Laura Chapman
    March 5, 2014 / 4:14 pm

    I've heard so many fantastic things about the Eyeko skinny eyeliner and very tempted to try it out. I've tried quite a few drugstore brands before but they always seem to dry out within a few weeks.Laura x | Life and Lipstick

  5. Niksi McCready
    March 5, 2014 / 10:49 pm

    I really like the eyeliner and if I'm in a splurge mood and need a new one I will pay out for it. However, the mascara is a major fail for me personally, It takes a whole heap of coats to really build up the volume and it dried out far too quickly compared to the old formula. I think they should go back to the drawing board on the formula for the mascara especially for the price tag. Great post. x

  6. Anna Maria
    March 6, 2014 / 7:04 am

    Wow i love the look of these products, Not heard of them before. Always love it when new brands come out and change things up. thanks hun xxAnna-Maria | http://www.topdrawfashion.com

  7. Becky Smith
    March 8, 2014 / 12:20 am

    I haven't tried the mascara but I did get the Skinny eyeliner when it was free with a magazine last year. I swatched it on my hand and it didn't appear to flow very well so I put it to one side planning to try it out later. When I went back to it later on I found that it had almost completely dried out and wouldn't flow at all, so it went in the bin. I may have just had a bad one but I wouldn't risk paying £12 to try it again. Becky @ The Little Blog of Beauty

Leave a Reply


Looking for Something?